Clash of ethics and quest for a perfect next generation in the designer baby supermarket - Instablogs
Clash of ethics and quest for a perfect next generation in the designer baby supermarket
Kanchan , New Delhi: May 16 2007
Made Popular May 16 2007

Clash of ethics and quest for a perfect next generation in the designer baby supermarketSome teased her by calling her a freak of nature, others referred to her as a retard, and she did not even register what they meant, because she had Down syndrome; however, if her mother had gone in for a Pre-implantation genetic diagnosis, she would not even have been born.

Good health is wealth, but if you are born with a disease, you cross each year with the notion that you have just a few more moments to live. Today with tests, one can get to know of diseases that the baby might have. Moving a step further, Pre-implantation genetic diagnosis allows parents to choose only those babies that are free of genetic diseases. PGD is an expensive procedure currently offered only to couples at risk of having a child suffering from a serious genetic disease. But there is nothing inherent in the technology that limits it to such uses.

Being a eugenic technology, pre-implantation diagnosis and selection is controversial. Apart, from selecting non-disease embryos, pre-implantation genetic diagnosis can also be used to design specific traits in babies. It could also be used to have babies of a particular sex. Parents may someday be able to go beyond weeding out undesirable traits and start actually inserting the genes they want, perhaps even genes that have been crafted in a lab.

These traits may be of a cosmetic or behavioral nature, such as a particular height, color of eyes, what body type they will have and conceivably, even their IQ and personality type. Humans now have power over “natural selection” and will attempt to play God! To get the perfect next generation they will eventually end up setting factories of birth to create a child to order. It would probably become the ultimate shopping experience to design your baby. Then for a society, used to cosmetic surgery and psychopharmacology, is it that big a step? Will the next step be cloning for those who are infertile?

Screening Genetic Diseases
Clash of ethics and quest for a perfect next generation in the designer baby supermarket
When a baby is born with a birth defect, the first question usually asked by the parents is “how did this happen?” Currently, around 4,000 genetic disorders are known with more being discovered. Most disorders are quite rare and affect one person in every several thousands or millions.

Many birth defects can be diagnosed before birth with special tests through a Prenatal Diagnosis:

• Fetal ultrasound during pregnancy can give information about the possibility of certain birth defects, but ultrasound is not 100 percent accurate.
• A chromosome analysis, whether performed on a blood sample or cells from the amniotic fluid or placenta, is over 99.9 percent accurate.

What is Pre-implantation genetic diagnosis (PGD)?

Pre-implantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) tests early-stage embryos produced through in vitro fertilization (IVF) for the presence of a variety of conditions. PGD does not involve the genetic modification of human embryos. Embryos free of conditions that would cause serious disease can be implanted in a woman’s uterus and allowed to develop into a child.

People who oppose the destruction of human embryos in general are necessarily opposed to PGD; however, for some, PGD is preferable to aborting a fetus affected by a medical condition that has been identified through prenatal screening.

As far as use of pre-implantation diagnosis to remove genetic diseases is concerned, it provides much hope to those having lost their family members to the same. Beyond that, designer babies remain a step closer to genetic screening. Gene therapy lives up to its promise of delivering perfect babies. However, in our quest for perfection, we might just lose our humanity. Organisms emerge from a complex interaction of genes and environment. To be a champion you need a particular environment. Will then these designer babies be able to fulfill the expectations of their parents? Will these babies be made to feel like second-class citizens? Alternatively, will they take over the world?

Image credit: [1], [2], [3]

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
0 Stars
Rekha
Bangalore, India
That’s an interesting story.

“Perfection is immutable. But for things imperfect, change is the way to perfect them.”

Its good to see technological advancements especially if they help people get over their worries of having babies free of genetic diseases once and for all. When the same technology is misused, it could be a disaster when you think of parents discussing the looks of a perfect baby and fighting over the qualities they expect to see in it; A single goof-up could actually prove it costlier!!

Anyway its hardly exciting to imagine a perfect world!
0 Stars
The world is full of many homeless orphans. They are also the children of the world and need parents and homes. Infertile parents should take them instead of resorting to cloning.
0 Stars
We do not yet know the long-term effects of eugenic! They could be disastrous. So BEWARE!
0 Stars
Kalpana
Raipur, India
A Very good story. The problem is that this technology starts out with preventing diseases and ,many harmful syndromes, but utimately it ends with designing children.
1 Stars
Designer babies in another futuristic concept that is within the ambit of genetic engineering, theoretically.

Darwin’s theory of ‘survival of the fittest’ also concludes that specie with the hardiest mutated genes will ultimately survive the ever changing parameters of the environment around.

Those who are working on ‘cloning’, project that the male of the specie can be rendered futile because the whole process of reproduction can be achieved through cloning itself.

Amidst conflicting theories about trying to develop a super race or a super human, it will only be nature and its unpredictable principles that will determine survival and advancement of any individual or specie.

There is a whole debate over abortion that is opposed by Roman Catholics and many other religions. Should man overtake the decision from ‘Nature’ of who should be born and who should not be.

Besides, the opposition from religious institutions, issues of human ethics and human rights are in conflict.

The cloning experiments done on sheep in UK have not proved that a super race of sheep can be developed.

Cloning, stem cell therapies, developing super humans or genetically modifying the embryos are all in the realm of ‘future’ but how does the human specie reacts to it has potential dangers.
0 Stars
Vinod
Shimla, India
Kanchan, well researched article. New invention of science for the good humanity. Now parents can make sure the healthy origin of their kids. Great! But after reading the story One question is striking to me- Can we people challenge the sovereignty of the Almighty to give birth and to decide death time?
Add your Comment